Selection for this week
Some Pros about the stock
Some Cons about the stock
Why the Quants like this stock
Criteria for choosing
The previous selections
Quick Links

The momentum stocks in the portfolio as a group rose slightly since last Thursday. The Portfolio is currently up 3% compared to the corresponding equal weight index that is up 1%, over the same time period.

This will be the last time the criteria for maintaining the Portfolio is appended to the end of this newsletter. Starting next week, the criteria can be found in the link provided in Quick Links at the end of the current newsletter.

Add: VLO (Valero Energy)

What does the company do?

Valero Energy Corporation is a San Antonio-based producer, marketer, and seller of petroleum-based and lower-carbon transportation fuels and petrochemical products. It operates through three segments—Refining, Renewable Diesel, and Ethanol—and markets products under brands including Valero, Diamond Shamrock, Shamrock, Ultramar, and Texaco. Founded in 1980, Valero operates across the U.S., Canada, the U.K., Ireland, and parts of Latin America.

Why Some Investors Are Bullish

Record second-quarter earnings.
Valero reported record Q2 2026 net income of $3.7 billion, or $12.62 per share, compared with $714 million, or $2.28 per share, a year earlier. Adjusted EPS was $12.54 versus the $10.11 consensus estimate, a $2.43 beat.

All three operating segments delivered significant improvement.
Refining operating income surged to $4.47 billion from $1.27 billion, renewable diesel swung to $717 million from a $79 million loss, and ethanol operating income increased to $318 million from $54 million. The improvement was driven by stronger gasoline and diesel margins, higher renewable-diesel product prices, and favorable ethanol economics, including clean-fuel production credits.

Refining fundamentals remained favorable heading into Q3.
Management cited low global refined-product inventories, limited excess refining capacity, resilient transportation-fuel demand and continued disruptions affecting Middle Eastern and Russian refining capacity. Management said refining margins and capture rates were stronger early in Q3, providing a constructive near-term backdrop.

Strong liquidity and shareholder returns.
Valero ended June with $7.9 billion of cash and about $12.7 billion of total liquidity, while net debt-to-capitalization was approximately 11%. The company returned $2.6 billion to shareholders during Q2 and declared a quarterly dividend of $1.20 per share.

The stock still carries a relatively low forward earnings multiple.
At roughly $424 per share, Valero trades at around 8.5x current fiscal-year consensus EPS, based on current estimates near $49 per share.

What Bears Are Worried About

Refining earnings are highly cyclical.
The Q2 results benefited from exceptionally strong refining margins, and investors should be cautious about extrapolating those conditions indefinitely. Valero’s earnings can decline sharply when fuel margins normalize, crude differentials change, or previously disrupted refining capacity returns to service.

The stock is now at record highs, raising valuation and expectations risk.
The original comparison to a $320.24 52-week high is outdated: VLO closed at $424.10 on October 7, 2026, a new 52-week high, after gaining 1.16% that day. The stock’s dramatic run means investors are now paying substantially more for the same underlying earnings stream, while the current average analyst price target remains below the share price.

Geopolitical, policy and renewable-fuels risks remain.
Valero’s unusually strong earnings are partly tied to favorable refining conditions and geopolitical supply disruptions that may not persist, while its renewable-fuels operations face policy, feedstock and regulatory uncertainty.

Why the Quants like this stock

P/E Non-GAAP (FWD) B+ 8.45
PEG Non-GAAP (FWD) A 0.3
Revenue Growth (YoY) B- 12.66%
EPS FWD Long Term Growth (3-5Y CAGR) A 28.38%
ROE Growth (FWD) A+ 45.93%
Return on Common Equity (TTM) A 29.31%
3M Price Performance A+ 59.30%
FY1 Up Revisions (last 90 days) 18 up 0 down

Latest Quarter’s Earnings
Announce Date 7/30/2026
EPS GAAP Actual $12.62 (Beat by $2.46)
EPS Normalized Actual $12.54 (Beat by $2.41)
Revenue Actual $44.48B
Revenue Surprise Beat by $6.05B

My View

Valero’s Q2 report was exceptional, with record earnings, strong performance across all three segments, substantial cash generation and a strong balance sheet. The bigger question for investors now is how much of that profitability is sustainable as refining margins normalize and the stock trades near record highs. Valero is scheduled to report Q3 2026 results before the market opens on October 22.

Previous Selections:

Top Quant Stock of the Week Criteria

I am using a Quantitative research platform that provides a daily list of top-ranked stocks to buy or sell, based on a Comprehensive Quant Score. This Quant system uses computer algorithms to come up with its rankings. This score incorporates multiple factors, including valuation, growth, profitability, momentum, and EPS revisions.

I will be giving heavy weight to strong momentum and strong EPS revisions to make the weekly selection. Then, I will use my tested proprietary criteria to sort and then break any tie.

One stock will be selected each week. That would make 52 selections a year if I don’t miss any weeks because of internet problems.

The hold times for the stocks added will be 1 week to years. Although a 1 week hold would be rare, it could happen if the stocks Quant metrics took a big nose dive right after being selected. If an added stock maintains its good metrics, it will be kept in the portfolio until it doesn’t. No time limit. The Quant system will tell me when it is time to let it go. So the hold time is short, medium and long depending on the Quant system metrics.

All countries are included. ADR’s are ok but Pink Sheet stocks will not be allowed.

Certain Industries are excluded. My testing shows they do not perform well using Quantitative rankings. Two of the main ones are BioTechnology and Pharmacueticals.

The Remove Criteria: Once the stock no longer qualifies to be retained in the Portfolio, it will be removed. This could be because the companies metrics have deteriorated since selection, it is involved in a buyout or financial reporting problems.

Once a stock has been added to the Active list, it will not be added to. No doubling down.

The stocks considered are larger small cap, mid cap, large cap and Mega cap. They will be fairly easy to trade with opening or closing market orders as one of the ways to enter and exit positions.

It should be expected that about 50 stocks will be Active in the Portfolio in any given week, once it gets to the two year mark.

All stocks are added as equal weight. No rebalancing is to occur.

To be considered for addition, the stock has to be in the top group of Quant rankings for just several weeks. This is to allow newly upgraded stocks to qualify quickly. Hopefully, this will catch a couple of strong momentum stocks early in their move.

Once a stock is removed for cause, it can be added back in once it meets the add criteria. No waiting period is required.

There will be no limits on percentages of stocks in the Portfolio by Sector or Industry.

NEW: The divisor for the live performance calculation will be the number of stocks in the portfolio at the last month end. This is likely to vary each month.

Quick Links

All content on this site is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Consult relevant financial professionals in your country of residence to get personalized advice before you make any trading or investing decisions. This post was written with the assistance of artificial intelligence. The original ideas and final review are human-generated. Disclaimer